Business As Usual: Please note that Brookman’s services to clients remain uninterrupted during the pandemic. Read more

Appeal against contact order granted

Date: April 20th, 2016 - Written by: Brookman Solicitors



A father’s fight to maintain contact with his son came a step closer recently, it was revealed in Family Law Week, when he won a second appeal against a case which originally saw all contact restricted between the man and his son.

In the original case heard in February last year at the Family Court in Reading, a young boy’s step-father had applied both for an adoption order and a no order for contact, thereby cutting off all contact between the biological father and the boy. His Honour Judge Oliver permitted both orders, based principally on an annexe A report.

An annexe A report is a document prepared by a local authority officer, based on research into the case. Its aim is to ensure the safeguarding of a child, particularly where that child is not represented in the adoption proceedings.
Six months after the original hearing, the case came before His Honour Judge Tolson QC. The judge heard that there were several issues which effectively made the annexe A report flawed. Of most concern was the fact that the social worker who had carried out the assessment on the boy’s biological father – a necessary part of an annexe A report – was in fact a colleague of the boy’s mother. In addition, the report failed to address the key question of whether the boy had been alienated from his biological father.

The question was then debated, as to whether the report was biased, and HHJ Tolson instructed that another, independent social worker, should address the issues of adoption and contact. In addition, he ordered that the annexe A should have an addendum, to highlight the areas which had been identified as being flawed.

An appeal was granted, to which the step-father and mother were initially opposed but later took up a more neutral position. The appeal took place at the Court of Appeal in November and was heard by Lord Justice Richards, Rt. Hon. Sir Ernest Ryder and Lord Justice Sales.

The day prior to the proceedings, the boy’s step-father and mother wrote to the court, explaining that they would be absent for childcare reasons but that they offered no strong opposition to a revised annexe A being submitted, provided that their son’s viewpoint was accurately recorded and interpreted.

The court found that the original annexe A document was indeed flawed and so should not be relied upon as evidence but removed from the bundle. Thereafter, the submission of a new annexe A by an independent social worker was ordered.


Google Reviews

Brookman Solicitors

61 Reviews

Jamie Warnes 16/03/2020

Excellent service. I had a consultation directly with Mr Brookman and his advice and guidance was very clear and helpful. Would highly recommend.

Deana Kendall 12/02/2020

I had been referred by a friend who has a close connection with the firm. I met with Mr Henry Brookman who offered me a free initial consultation to discuss my matter. Mr Brookman is very thorough and has great attention to detail and care. I genuinely feel that he has a great understanding of my circumstances and situation. Moving forward, I have received continuous updates (when relevant) regarding developments to my situation and all correspondences are clear. I feel confident with Mr Brookman's guidance and excellent team! Though my matter is still on-going for the time being, I cannot highly recommend enough! In any event, I will always be eternally grateful to Mr Brookman and his team.

Emma Hearse 03/02/2020

I had an initial consultation with Mr. Brookman, his advice was extremely thorough and relevant. I would recommend Brookman Solicitors.

Caroline Keane 17/01/2020

It was great to have a free initial consultation with Henry Brookman. He answered my questions, and I finished the conversation knowing what I needed to do next in order to resolve matters.

Niamh Tracey Smith 10/12/2019

Highly recommended. Speak to Senior Partner Henry Brookman directly to put your mind at ease and for expert guidance. Invaluable.