A few weeks ago we read some dramatic criticisms of the courts in the case of an Italian mother and Essex County Council.  One headline said “Women’s baby taken from womb by Social Services.”  There was supposedly a “secret” hearing in the Court of Protection which led to this treatment of the Italian mother.

Shortly before Christmas the President of the Family Division commented on this when he dealt with an application by Essex County Council for a Reporting Restriction Order.  While at the same time suggesting that it is the responsibility of the press to get the facts right, he said that the media can hardly be blamed for inaccuracy if for whatever reason none of the relevant information has been made public.  He said the case must “surely stand as final, stark and irrefutable demonstration of the pressing need for radical changes… as to transparency.”

But first, the facts as he laid them out.

The Italian mother came on a short visit to England in 2012.  She was pregnant at the time.  Following a mental health episode she was compulsorily detained pursuant to the Mental Health Act, presumably for her own safety.  Because she was about to give birth, and there were complications the NHS Trust – note, not Essex County Council social workers – made an urgent application for the Court of Protection to authorise a Caesarean section, because the mother did not have the mental capacity at that time to make a decision in the best interests of herself and the baby.  The baby was born by caesarean section and the next day Essex County Council began care proceedings, again presumably because the mother was not in a mental state to care for the baby.  Council social workers supervised some contact with the mother, who returned to Italy about two months after the birth.  A few months after that Essex County Court asked the Court for leave to place the baby for adoption, and the court granted that in October 2013.  The mother attended at least one hearing in England, and never appealed any of the Orders.  Instead, she took various proceedings in the Italian courts, but unsurprisingly nothing resulted from those.

The judge, Sir James Munby, pointed out that logically there were three particular competing interests that he had to consider : –

  1. The public has an interest in knowing and discussing what has been done in this case.  He said it was hard to imagine a case “which more obviously and compellingly requires the public debate to be free and unrestrictive.”
  2. The mother has an equally obvious and compelling claim to be allowed to tell her story to the world.  In free society, parents who feel aggrieved at the judicial system should be free to complain as they see fit.  The implication is that reporting restrictions are not intended to protect the feelings of judges.
  3. The baby, in its new adopted home has a compelling claim to privacy and anonymity.

Sir James concluded that the continuing anonymisation of the child was an overwhelming argument and his or her anonymity should be protected.  Beyond that, he would not go.  If the mother wished to identify herself, that was entirely her decision and the public indeed had an interest in knowing and discussing what had been done.  As Sir James said, “how can the family justice system blame the media for inaccuracy in the reporting of family cases if for whatever reason none of the relevant information has been put before the public?”

Got a question? Ask us now…

Kindly complete the form below to send an enquiry. Your message will be sent to one of our solicitors. Discretion is guaranteed.

Your Information

  • Consider including information such as: the name of your spouse (if relevant), the country you live in, the background to your problem.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Over 2000 FREE
consultations and counting…

Our free consultation can help you more clearly understand the legal issues relating your case and what your options are to move forward.

Request your free consultation

Or send us an enquiry

Today I had my free initial consultation with partner Henry Brookman over the phone. He had a clear understanding of my situation based on the info I provided in advance and provided me with sound advice and guidance to move forward. Many thanks.

Aug 2022   H. J.

Really appreciated Brookman's advice and support. Most lawyers charge extortionate fees just for an initial conversation but not Henry. Thanks for all your advice and time.

Jul 2022   Chloé

I had a consultation with the partner Henry Brookman. I can absolutely recommend him, he seemed knowledgeable, up to date and patient. I have found him to be straightforward in the answers he gives and down to earth. 100% recommended.

Jun 2022   Michael P

I have no hesitation whatsoever in recommending Henry Brookman. His advice came in promptly when solicited, and was excellent. He is a thoughtful and very professional lawyer. He understood perfectly well the issue I presented him with, and gave me excellent advice in a family law related matter.

May 2022   Philip Hands

From my first contact with the firm I was treated courteously and promptly. I was offered a pro bono meeting shortly after making contact. Mr Brookman is clearly a very experienced professional and in our meeting he gave me some well considered and objective advice about my rather complicated situation which spans more than one jurisdiction.

May 2022   Julian Peachey

I had an initial consultation with Henry Brookman regarding prenuptial agreements and found him to be very helpful and knowledgeable.

Mar 2022   Simon Brooks

I had a free telephone consultation yesterday with Gavin Yeung. He could not have been more helpful and reassuring as he calmly and patiently worked through my situation to provide me with clarity and piece of mind at a time it was really needed and emotions are running high.

Mar 2022   'K M'

I spoke with Aziz at Brookman Solicitors on the phone for an initial consultation and he is one of the friendliest lawyers I have met. He is clearly very experienced as he patiently explained me all the concepts and processes which are quite daunting for someone in my situation, and then focused on the actual questions I wanted to ask... I would highly recommend Aziz and Brookman Solicitors.

Feb 2022   'R'

I am grateful for Henry Brookman and his team for support they provided to me during very frustrating time of divorce. They respond promptly to any request. I felt more confident after I started the process with them. Henry listened carefully to me and took quick actions on my case. I highly recommend this team of real professionals even for non-UK citizens.

Feb 2022   Sezim Beksultanova

I had online consultation with the partner Henry Brookman today. I was very happy with the service. I found him to be very insightful, knowledgeable and provided sound advice, as well as being kind and patient. It was a very comfortable discussion and he sent an email detailing our discussion very quickly discussing in our meeting in depth. I am amazed by the service we got just from a free consultation. I would highly recommend these solicitors!

Jan 2022   Shirley Christopher

We spoke at length and at no point felt like he was rushing us and we felt very comfortable. After our discussion we were also quickly sent an email detailing everything we were discussing in our meeting in depth. I am amazed by the service we got just from a free consultation. I would highly recommend these solicitors!

Dec 2021   Tina

I was fortunate to spend an hour running through a few questions with Natasha Slabas. She was quick to grasp the points raised and proposed a sensible way forward. Would recommend

Dec 2021   Nick Powell

I cannot praise the professionalism and courtesy too highly. The advice given in a very complex divorce matter, was clear, concise, enlightening and inspiring.

Nov 2021   Mary Barn

I contacted Henry Brookman because of the complex international aspect of my divorce and I’m very glad I did... Henry took his time explaining all the pro’s and contra’s... I now have a much clearer view over the situation and feel more confident going forward. I’m very grateful for the excellent advice I’ve received and not feeling rushed during the meeting.

Nov 2021   'A B'

Talitha offers sound advice, asks the right questions and advises you with what you need to know not just what you want to hear. I have no hesitation in recommending her services.

Sep 2021   Anu Vidyarthi

Google Reviews
Ask A Question

Contact Us

If you have questions, contact us now, we can help you.

Enquire Now

Or call us on +44 (0)20 7430 8470