indiasurrogacy

As reported in Family Law Week, a commercial surrogacy agreement between an Indian woman and a British couple led to months of delay, until the children were permitted to travel to their new home in the UK.

After they learned that the in-vitro fertilisation over in India had been successful, the couple visited the Indian Consulate in Birmingham, to notify them of the imminent birth and to supply the surrogacy agreement, which would allow them to obtain an Indian medical visitor’s visa.

Twin girls were born in May 2014. The British parents duly travelled over to India and secured legal advice, to ensure the surrogacy agreement was legal. Their names were subsequently included on the children’s birth certificates.

Unfortunately, they were then forced to return to the UK at the end of May, as they had not yet received British passports for their babies. A week or so later, the British High Commission returned the applications.

The commissioning mother returned to India the following month and the biological mother signed a consent form, allowing her to again apply for British passports for the girls. A significant delay was then experienced, meaning that the passports weren’t actually issued until May 2015. Although the reasons for this have not been fully explained, it was suggested that there was some doubt about the authenticity of the death certificate of the husband of the biological mother and indeed it appears that there were even questions about the woman’s own identity. Concern had also been raised about the possibility that the applications for parental orders may have been used to gain British citizenship or to work around English immigration law. It must be emphasised however, that none of these claims were ever substantiated.

Details of this delay subsequently led Mrs Justice Russell to issue guidance in respect of all international surrogacy cases where parental orders are sought. This guidance has been approved by the President of the Family Division.

Typically, international surrogacy is a very complex issue, which is why such cases should always be referred to a High Court Judge of the Family Division. In this particular instance, the proceedings had not been allocated appropriately, which, it was agreed, had contributed to the delay.

In addition, Mrs Justice Russell stressed that when completing a parental order report, the reporter must meet with both the child and the applicants to assess their welfare, unless sufficient evidence has already been obtained or in exceptional circumstances.

It is unfortunate that the couple experienced such a significant delay, due at least in part to a failure by the legal system to follow procedure. This delay undoubtedly caused them undue stress and financial pressure. However, this case has had the positive outcome of reinforcing the legal proceedings required and outlining the need for specialist knowledge from a High Court judge in the Family Division.

Got a question? Ask us now…

Kindly complete the form below to send an enquiry. Your message will be sent to one of our solicitors. Discretion is guaranteed.

Your Information

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Consider including information such as: the name of your spouse (if relevant), the country you live in, the background to your problem.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Terms of Service and our Privacy Notices apply.

Over 2000 FREE
consultations and counting…

Our free consultation can help you more clearly understand the legal issues relating your case and what your options are to move forward.

Request your free consultation

Or send us an enquiry

I had a video call yesterday with Phillip Morton who was extremely well informed about my circumstances and offered helpful advice about my situation.

Nov 2026   Lisa Hamblen

I sought an initial consultation from Henry Brookman... His advice was very well informed and he answered all of my queries and also provided a recommendation on a way forward.

Oct 2026   Liza Romanovskaya

Samantha was extremely helpful, professional, and informative. She took the time to explain everything clearly and made sure I understood the advice she provided.

Oct 2026   Lorrin Chantrey

I had a consultation with Henry Brookman and found him extremely helpful, knowledgeable and professional.

Sep 2026   Sodai Hopen

I had a very thorough consultation with Mr. Henry Brookman, he is very experienced in family law & was very professional.

Sep 2026   Jan Ball

I had a consultation with Henry Brookman regarding a family law matter and had an excellent experience... His advice was clear, practical and refreshingly honest.

Aug 2026   Zain Mirz

In an initial consultation I met Lauren Blythe, who I would highly recommend. Lauren is very knowledgeable and provided me with clear information.

Aug 2026   "S"

Had an initial consultation with Lauren who is very polite, very knowledgeable and provided me with valuable information and next steps.

Jul 2026   Paul Murphy

Very helpful initial consultation. the solicitor was professional, listened carefully, and explained my options clearly without any pressure. I left with a much better understanding of the process and my next steps. Thank you.

Jul 2026   Khadija Mouaddab

Google Reviews
Ask A Question

Contact Us

If you have questions, contact us now, we can help you.

Enquire Now

Or call us on +44 (0)20 7430 8470