It’s not uncommon for one spouse to behave badly during the divorce process. The end of a marriage awakens all kinds of emotions and can lead to unreasonable behaviour that makes finding a solution more difficult.
In this article we will look at some ways to counteract negative attitudes your spouse might display during the divorce process. We won’t examine the implications of domestic abuse here but if your spouse behaves violently towards you or you believe his or her conduct amounts to another type of domestic abuse you should seek urgent advice on ways to keep you and your children safe. We discuss the resources available to you in more detail here.
Starting Your Divorce When Your Ex Won’t Cooperate
With the arrival of no-fault divorce in England and Wales in 2022 there was an expectation that the acrimony associated with the divorce process would reduce. If you want to divorce you now don’t have to prove unreasonable behaviour or assign blame. You simply have to declare that your marriage has broken down irretrievably. Previously a hostile spouse could have – in certain cases – delayed your ability to even start the process.
Resolution, the group that campaigns for a more constructive approach to divorce and family law disputes reported on the one year anniversary of the no-fault reform that removing blame had ‘started to make the divorce process kinder and has increased the chances of successful non-court dispute resolution’.
However there was never any guarantee that no-fault divorce would put an end to the type of obstructive and ill-tempered behaviour of aggrieved spouses. Behaviour that we have encountered over the years in our work as specialist divorce lawyers in London. Despite removal of the previous requirement to prove fault at the beginning of the divorce procedure we regularly see underlying acrimony transferred or delayed to the point in proceedings when finances and child arrangements are being discussed.
Sometimes a spouse who is reluctant to divorce will refuse to even acknowledge that they have received the divorce application from the court. In such circumstances you can ensure the divorce proceeds by asking the court to accept that you’ve done all within your power to ensure your spouse has received notification of your application – ‘deemed service’ or you can ask the court to ‘dispense’ with service.
It’s also worth mentioning that couples can now make joint applications for divorce, and this is one way to reduce overall tension. However there are significant drawbacks in joint applications, including the danger that one spouse will refuse to engage constructively and making the securing of a Final Order more difficult.
Using A Solicitor
When both sides each engage an experienced solicitor, difficult behaviour by one side will often become less of an issue. This isn’t because the solicitors are there to offer relationship advice (for that you need a specialist marriage counsellor) but it’s because couples tend to listen to the advice of two arm’s length professionals – particularly when they are paying for that advice. And family lawyers will usually highlight the need for their clients to engage with the divorce process in as constructive process as possible.
As we know many people now represent themselves during the divorce process, and it may be that your spouse decides to do this. It’s worth remembering that when you instruct a divorce lawyer you are not just getting someone with the expertise to advise you on your case – you are engaging someone to communicate with your spouse on your behalf, reducing the occasions in which you might be affected by difficult behaviour.
There Are Alternatives To Court
It may be that your spouse’s unhelpful conduct is driven by the idea that he or she is being forced to ‘go to court’. You – or your solicitor – should highlight the alternatives to letting a judge decide the outcome of your divorce. Family mediation and informal negotiation can often take some of the heat from the whole divorce process and help you and your spouse find an agreement. At Brookman we actively encourage these less formal methods of dealing with family law disputes. Like many family law firms we are members of the industry body Resolution mentioned above, committed to resolving divorce in non-confrontational ways.
Don’t Let Your Spouse’s Behaviour Dictate Events
You can minimise the impact of obstructive behaviour by acting proactively. This means having all your financial details and information on your children to hand so that your solicitor can run the case as efficiently as possible. It also means concentrating on other matters, including childcare and day-to-day matters instead of allowing your spouse’s behaviour to overwhelm you and cloud your judgment.
Do You Have To Meet Your Spouse In Person?
Your divorce may take many months to resolve, and it’s inevitable that you will have to communicate with your spouse about issues regarding the children, household bills and other financial matters. Meeting face-to-face won’t always be a good idea. We often advise clients to adopt other methods of communication, including email and text early in in the process so that it becomes the default method of interacting with your spouse and reduces the opportunity for conflict.
Can Spouse’s Conduct Affect The Financial Settlement?
‘Conduct’ is one of the factors taken into account when deciding on how to divide marital assets. The relevant legislation states that the court must consider:
“the conduct of each of the parties… if that conduct is such that it would in the opinion of the court be inequitable to disregard it…”
Cases where the conduct of your spouse could potentially be taken into account by the court include:
- Where a spouse’s conduct is particularly extreme (in one historical case the wife’s settlement was reduced because it was found that she had incited others to murder her estranged husband)
- If one spouse injures the other in such a way as to reduce his or her earning capacity
- When the conduct has direct financial consequences for the other spouse. This could be as a result of one spouse hiding assetsfrom the other or because one spouse begins to overspend in an attempt to reduce the amount available to the other in any settlement
- Where an uncooperative spouse does not provide full and frank disclosure of assets then the court can draw adverse inferences when reaching a decision. This could mean the court assumes they have more assets than they actually have and adjust the financial order accordingly
Case Study: VS v OP (2024)
The 2024 case of VS v OP demonstrates the kind of non-cooperation that can affect the final settlement. Not only should the judge’s reasoning reassure people faced with a difficult ex who refuses to engage, it should also serve as a warning to those who seek to frustrate the wishes of a spouse who simply wants to sort matters out as efficiently and fairly as possible.
Turning to the case itself, the wife – according to the judge – ‘deliberately flouted’ court orders, refused to disclose assets and breached a number of orders that had criminal sanctions attached to them. The result was that the court did not have the full picture of the family finances.
The judge highlighted the uniqueness of family remedy proceedings: unlike other civil cases where a court can strike out a defence or give one side a summary judgement when orders are ignored, this is not possible in the family court.
In the circumstances the judge refused to allow the case to drag on. (There had already been seven hearings in a case where the assets were relatively modest.) Despite not having all the requested information he decided nevertheless to proceed. He concluded that the wife had engaged in such serious misconduct that he was justified in departing from the equality provision. Her behaviour had added significantly to the duration and expense of the case, and he awarded the husband almost 70% of the total assets.
Comment
The stress of a divorce can be made much worse when one spouse refuses to co-operate in the process. We’ve looked at ways you can try to reduce conflict and avoid court. But if you are unable to reach private agreement and you do want the court to consider your ex’s misconduct (dragging out proceedings or not attending court, for example) you need to make your case at the earliest opportunity. You should also be prepared to provide the court with concrete evidence of how the conduct has impacted you.
In practice courts will only reduce one party’s financial award because of their conduct in limited circumstances. The case of VS v OP discussed above shows that in extreme cases courts will depart from the principle of equality and penalise a spouse who does not engage with the court process. What is more likely however is that the court will orders an uncooperative spouse to pay some or all your legal costs. The power of the court to make negative costs orders can also cover a situation where, irrespective of any court hearing, a spouse has refused to privately negotiate in an open and responsible way.