In recent years there has been significant progress in the way the courts and those involved in the family court system approach the issue of domestic abuse. The Domestic Abuse Act, 2021(The Act) emphasises that domestic abuse is not just physical violence but can also be emotional or result from controlling or coercive behaviour by the abuser.
The Act also makes clear that economic abuse is a type of domestic abuse which – as we discuss below – takes many forms. It may involve limiting a spouse’s access to bank accounts during the marriage, for example or dragging out financial discussions unnecessarily during divorce proceedings.
Indeed there is an increasing awareness of this latter kind of economic abuse that extends beyond the breakdown of the marriage. In October 2024 Resolution published a detailed report on potential ways to tackle this sort of abuse. Below we look at different ways a spouse can inflict economic abuse, and we outline the main points of the Resolution report.
What is economic abuse?
The Act defines economic abuse as
‘any behaviour that has a substantial adverse effect on the [victim]’s ability to
(a) acquire, use or maintain money or other property, or
(b) obtain goods or services.
In addition to ongoing economic abuse that takes place during a marriage the impact such abuse has when it begins to feature in divorce financial negotiations is recognised in the Resolution report.
Examples of ongoing economic abuse include:
- A spouse refusing to provide full and frank disclosure of their finances as required in Form E
- A spouse’s refusal to provide sufficient financial resources during the divorce process. This could be done with the intention of preventing the other spouse from being able to access legal advice.
Economic abuse and the s25 factors
Conduct is one of the factors judges can consider when making financial orders in divorce proceedings (Matrimonial Causes Act, 1973 s25). But the kind of abusive behaviour outlined above is not usually regarded as relevant for the purposes of the financial order. In practice conduct, including economic abuse, is only taken into account in exceptional circumstances. The Resolution report suggests that conduct amounting to economic abuse should in fact go towards determining the level of financial awards – even in unexceptional cases.
The research behind the report showed that the issue of economic abuse was raised much more often in non-court dispute resolution like mediation (NCDR) than in court proceedings. There is a good reason for this disparity. If financial abuse is not raised at the initial stage of proceedings on Section 4.4 of Form E, it is extremely difficult for a spouse to raise it as a relevant conduct issue once financial remedy proceedings are underway. (The implication is that financial abuse would be brought up more readily as an issue in court if the bar to raising it were not so high.)
Key recommendations of report on Domestic Abuse in Financial Remedy Proceedings
In Resolution’s Domestic Abuse in Financial Remedy Proceedings report the authors call for nothing less than a wholesale cultural shift from all those involved in the family justice system. Only then they believe will the needs of survivors of domestic abuse seeking the resolution of their finances be met properly.
The key recommendations are:
- Non-disclosure of assets and financial details by a spouse must be confronted head on. The law should be modified to make it clear the duty of full and frank disclosure starts once parties engage in non-court dispute resolution (NCDR) – that is before financial remedy proceedings start.
- Advisors, judges and parties to proceedings should be realistic about the limitations of NCDR. We know that there is a move towards greater use of mediation and other forms of NCDR but the fact is, it is not suitable in every case – and very often in the case of domestic abuse, including economic abuse it is wholly inappropriate
- There should be greater awareness of the risks associated with NCDR. While there are advantages to settling financial matters out of court, the flexibility in alternative dispute resolution has a downside too. A financially abusive spouse for example can draw out negotiations unnecessarily or refuse to engage constructively, wearing the other spouse down and exacerbating abuse that existed during the marriage
- The appropriateness of NCDR should always be robustly and periodically questioned. If a family mediator exempts a couple from mediation on the grounds of domestic abuse, judges should not take issue with this or ask the spouses to reconsider mediation
- When there are sufficient matrimonial resources for both parties to be represented but one party is unable to instruct a solicitor because they have been denied access to funds, this should act as a red flag and an indication of possible economic abuse. Courts should have the power to order an abusive spouse to meet the costs of the interest payable on any litigation loan the other spouse may be forced to take out
- The report makes several suggestions about using costs orders to deter economic abuse. For example, if NCDR is deemed to be unsuitable because of domestic abuse and more expensive court proceedings are unavoidable then the perpetrator of the abuse should shoulder more of the costs of the proceedings
Comment
As members of Resolution we welcome this report. It advocates proper scrutiny of potential economic abuse and a practical approach to dealing with such behaviour in the kind of financial remedy proceedings our solicitors are regularly involved in. It’s now over to the Ministry of Justice and the top financial remedies judges to consider the proposals made in the report and take them forward.