Judges who make financial orders in divorce cases (or approve a privately agreed settlement) want the provisions to have finality. Enabling the parties to put the breakdown of the marriage behind them and get on with their lives is the priority. Following on from this, it’s no surprise that if one party subsequently wishes to change the terms of a financial order (for example because they lose their job, or their financial circumstances have changed for some other reason) courts will not entertain such a request lightly.

The 2021 case of BT v CU shows this clearly. There a husband failed to persuade the court that Covid19 had so disrupted his finances that he should be relieved of his obligation to comply with a lump sum payment schedule he had been ordered to make in his 2019 divorce proceedings.

Variation Of A Financial order

If, after your divorce, your financial circumstances change and you find it difficult to meet the terms of a financial settlement relating to maintenance, lump sum or other payments then you have two options:

  • You can try to reach an agreement with your spouse to change the existing payment regime. Do this before you breach any existing court order and ensure you record any agreement you make with your spouse to reduce or change the payments you are required to make.
  • Alternatively, you can ask the court to modify the agreement.

Before going down the family court route you should consider getting legal advice because courts are reluctant to alter financial orders. They will only do so in exceptional cases. A specialist family lawyer should be able to give you a good indication as to your chances of successfully varying an order before you incur significant court costs and other legal fees.

When deciding to change an existing financial order the courts apply what’s known as the ‘Barder’ principle, named after a 1987 case. In short if you are seeking to change a financial order you must be able to rely on an event that has had the effect of fundamentally undermining the entire basis on which the original order or settlement was made. Other elements of the Barder rule include:

  • The event relied on must occur within a short period of time from the original order
  • The requirement that the party wishing to change the order must apply to court as soon as possible after the event occurs
  • The requirement that any change to the order should not adversely affect a third party who has acquired property included in the order in good faith
  • The event must be unforeseeable. Note that the fall in value of an asset like a house will usually be viewed as the foreseeable consequence of normal market fluctuation

As we’ll see, the circumstances in which the courts will apply the Barder rule to overturn a financial order are extremely limited.

Covid19 And The Limitations Of Barder: BT v CU, 2021

It’s important to note that a simple change in your financial circumstances won’t qualify as a ‘Barder event.’ Redundancy, arguing that assets have been over or undervalued in the financial settlement or a change in the value of a specific asset are not likely to amount to Barder events in themselves –although as in all family court cases each case will be decided in its facts.

The case of BT v CU examined a financial order made in 2019 under which the

husband was ordered to pay the wife £950,000 in a series of lump sums. These commenced with £150,000 on 1 November 2019 and were due to be followed by four payments of £200,000 at yearly intervals commencing on 1 November 2020 and ending on 1 November 2023. A substantial part of the husband’s wealth was derived from a business he had set up before the marriage providing school meals (this business didn’t form part of the financial settlement).

The husband argued that when all schools closed in March 2020 as a result of the Covid19 lockdown he faced devastating financial consequences. The lockdown invalidated the fundamental assumptions on which the final order was based. As a result, he claimed that he was unable to discharge his unpaid obligations under the order.

Mostyn J disagreed fundamentally, saying that Covid19 was ‘probably not’ a Barder event. His reasoning is significant because it helpfully sheds light on the considerations applied when deciding if an event is unforeseeable in the context of a Barder application.

Mostyn J was unable to accept that the events that caused the downturn in the husband’s income were unforeseeable or that they invalidated a fundamental assumption on which the original financial order was based. On the contrary, in Mostyn J’s view, a reasonable person would have said in October 2019 that there was certainly a chance, ‘which could not sensibly be ignored’, that in the next year there would be an economic downturn which would have the effect of reducing turnover and increasing costs in the husband’s business.

The judge also highlighted that the basis on which the financial order had been approved was that the husband would be retaining assets which were risky. It was for that reason he was granted a greater than equal share of the matrimonial pot. In taking on the risk – and a greater share of assets he could not in hindsight return to the court and ask for his financial obligations to be reduced.

Comment

Clearly, it’s difficult to get the courts to alter a financial settlement. If you are having difficulty meeting your obligations, it’s important to take a pragmatic approach. Be open with your spouse and, ideally with the help of lawyers, make a sensible revised payment schedule, perhaps on a temporary basis until your circumstances improve. And remember if you really are unable to discharge lump sums or maintenance as required you can always make an application to the court to delay payment.

Got a question? Ask us now…

Kindly complete the form below to send an enquiry. Your message will be sent to one of our solicitors. Discretion is guaranteed.

Your Information

  • Consider including information such as: the name of your spouse (if relevant), the country you live in, the background to your problem.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Over 2000 FREE
consultations and counting…

Our free consultation can help you more clearly understand the legal issues relating your case and what your options are to move forward.

Request your free consultation

Or send us an enquiry

I had applied for a free consultation and I was contacted in a very short timeframe. Thank you so much for the insightful and thorough consultation, Kevin Danagher. You made me feel at ease and you provided clear expectations with the initial info I had provided... I have now a much better understanding on my query.

Feb 2024   Sonia Accardi

We had a very useful first consultation with Amber Matheson today. Amber took the time to understand our (somewhat complicated) set-up, and offered good, understandable advice on next steps. She followed up with a very thorough email clarifying what we had discussed. Highly recommended.

Feb 2024   Lucie

Lovely friendly experience. All questions were answered so that I understood completely.

Dec 2023   Ali Catlin

Very balanced, fair and pragmatic advice. Thoroughly recommend!!

Nov 2023   James Elliott

Henry graciously provided his time for a consultation. I found him to be highly knowledgeable, empathetic and he provided excellent advice which put my mind at ease. Would highly recommend Henry and his firm.

Oct 2023   Allan Ang

Henry Brookman went above and beyond during the free consultation, and even overran the allocated time. He provided invaluable professional advice in a courteous manner. I recommend his firm without reservation.

Sep 2023   Mario Ignatov

I only had my initial free review with Amelia yet I already feel much more strengthened in my legal and financial position. I am currently reflecting on the steps I want to take to negotiate my desired outcome of the financial settlement but, when I am ready to use the services of a lawyer, Amelia is definitely the top on my list.

Sep 2023   Nahid Toubia

I had a zoom consultation with Lauren Moir and she was incredible. Very patient, insightful and reassuring. She also advised me based on my previous conversations with another firm and also clarified various positions I am in. Highly recommend.

Aug 2023   Gary Hawes

I was very impressed with the friendly, helpful and professional service offered by Brookman Solicitors. The generous advice and knowledge offered during the initial free consultation has enabled us to have a much better understanding of our case and plan a way forward.

Jul 2023   Peter Jackson

I had a first consultation with Kevin, who very diligently and professionally provided an exhaustive overview of the divorce process and the best approach for my specific case.

Jul 2023   Giulia Matteo

Great service and excellent advice at the initial consultation. I would certainly recommend and use in the future.

Jul 2023   Tom James

Spoke to a kind solicitor this morning who took an hour of her time to talk me through some advice relating to a difficult separation.... She was clear and helpful with her advice, leaving me feeling much more confident with the process ahead of me.

Jun 2023   Luke Taylor

Mr Brookman provided very clear advice that left me with no doubt about the options and next steps. Getting specific advice with the requirements in the different jurisdictions was particularly useful so I won’t need to consult another lawyer outside of the UK

May 2023   Julian Anthony

From initial contact I found all staff extremely helpful and professional. My options were made clear, my query was dealt with in a sympathetic way. Would highly recommend Brookman Solicitors.

Mar 2023   seamus mcguinness

The initial consultation I have just completed with Henry Brookman was very informative; he was very open and honest about my situation, the legalities of the matter and the extent of how his firm could help.

Nov 2022   Kimberley Noakes

Google Reviews
Ask A Question

Contact Us

If you have questions, contact us now, we can help you.

Enquire Now

Or call us on +44 (0)20 7430 8470