Pre and post nuptial agreements are enforceable under English law – so long as certain conditions are met. The case of Radmacher in 2010 is generally accepted as having laid down the rules on nuptial agreements, and these are still applied today. In that case the Supreme Court decided that nuptial agreements should be recognised if they are:
‘freely entered into by each party with a full appreciation of the implications unless, in the circumstances prevailing, it would not be fair to hold the parties to their agreement..’
If your circumstances change after you’ve entered an agreement it makes sense to review it. An updated agreement that remains relevant to your existing circumstances stands more chance of being upheld by the courts if it is ever needed. Many advisors suggest agreements like these should be reviewed every five years or so, or when a major life event occurs. Below we explain why reviewing prenups and postnups matters, we list some of the occasion on which you may be prompted to review an agreement, and we outline what’s involved when you want to update your agreement.
What are your current circumstances?
As the comment from the Radmacher judgment above makes clear, courts will look at the effect of a pre or postnup in light of the circumstances that exist when the agreement comes into effect (i.e. when a relationship breaks down). The more time that passes from the signing of a pre or postnup, the more likely it is that the ‘prevailing circumstances’ will have altered to such an extent that the fairness of the original agreement has been undermined. This increases the possibility that the court won’t approve it. In separation and divorce cases this means the general law on financial remedies will be applied.
As a general principle then, a periodic review of your agreement is advisable.
When life changes
As your relationship matures and you undergo significant life events you should always consider how these might shape your financial position if you and your spouse or partner split up. Would the terms of the nuptial agreement meet your changed circumstances? Some events that often trigger a review of a prenup or postnup include:
- Marriage – Consider reviewing a prenup and converting it into a postnup when you get married to reflect your new status
- Birth of children – If you have children or adopt, demands on your time and finances change dramatically. Financial priorities and needs shift and you should consider whether these changes are reflected in your existing agreement.
- Change in finances – Where either spouse or civil partner receives an inheritance for example or there is a significant rise or fall in assets
- Relocation – If the family move abroad ensure that the existing agreement is compatible with any laws that apply in the new country of residence Our client map shows how courts in different countries apply different principles to the division of assets
- Illness – Disability and long-term health issues will change your financial needs and may render an agreement unfit for purpose
- Changes to the law could change the way an existing agreement is ultimately interpreted.
What is involved in updating your prenup or postnup?
Making changes to your agreement should be relatively straightforward Remember that the same conditions for making the agreement in the first case still apply:
- There must be full and frank disclosure of assets
- Both sides need independent advice
- The agreement must be fair to both parties
- It can’t be used to avoid legal obligations
- There can be no suggestion that one party has forced the other to sign the agreement
Comment
You should always get advice on whether an update to your nuptial agreement is necessary so that it’s done in a proportionate and cost-effective way. In our experience individuals are sometimes unwilling to spend the time and money necessary to renew an agreement. This is understandable. There is of course a degree of sensitivity around nuptial agreements generally. Once an agreement is signed, couples can be reluctant to revisit an area that addresses the possibility that the relationship will break down.
Reviews can also inject the instability and uncertainty around financial matters that the original agreement was designed to address.
Nevertheless, leaving your nuptial agreement untouched, over possibly many years of marriage increases the likelihood that if you do wish to implement it, the courts won’t approve it.