Belgian TV Channel, RTBF, Interviews Henry Brookman

Date: June 18th, 2012 - Written by: Brookman Solicitors

Henry Brookman comments on a recent high profile case in Belgium concerning the alleged abduction of a child to the UK by her mother.

An English couple were living in Brussels when the wife left for the UK, taking the couple’s daughter with her. There were proceedings in Belgium for custody.

Both Belgium and the UK are signatories to the Hague Convention and Brussels II Regulation.  The rules dictate that a child taken to another country without consent should be returned to the country in which they were last resident.  There are few arguments against a Hague Convention claim other than, for instance, the defending parent being able to demonstrate that their spouse consented to the child leaving the country.  

In this case, the English High Court refused the father’s request to have his daughter returned to Belgium.  This led to the Belgium court suggesting that the English Judge must have misunderstood the evidence and also to criticise CAFCASS (the organisation that advises courts regarding the best interests of children).

In Henry Brookman’s interview with RTBF, he explained that consent does not have to be explicit, it can be inferred from circumstances.  In this case, the English Judge has inferred, from the subsequent actions of the father, that the father did not object to the child staying in the UK.  In essence, because the father initially appeared to knowingly stand by without raising objection, the Judge was led to infer that consent was implied – and therefore refused the father’s request.  The interpretation of the evidence is all critical and, the English Judge had indeed followed the correct rules.

See Henry Brookman’s interview online here (from 21 minutes 40 seconds into the programme).

If you would like to know more about this issue please contact Brookman Solicitors for more information.


Google Reviews

Brookman Solicitors

51 Reviews

Jo Hannah 09/03/2019

I am very thankful to Mr Henry Brookman for his time, understanding and advice. I would highly recommend this firm.

Jeffrey Schenck 06/02/2019

Henry Brookman listened carefully and provided clear, thoughtful, sound advice that took into account the complexity of my situation. All of my dealings with the firm were handled with sensitivity and respect. I would definitely recommend the services of Brookman Solicitors.

Ilona Galiyeva 29/01/2019

I’ve dealt with Mr. Brookman himself and he is very peasant to work with. Listens to your demands and is very helpful in terms of providing advice.

Milla Linke 24/01/2019

Mr Brookman is very professional and helpful. After my initial consultation I have more clarity and understanding into my situation. I would highly recommend this firm.

Mr Man 09/01/2019

VERY PROFESSIONAL . My initial telephone contact to this firm was handled very professionally. First impressions really do matter. The details of my enquiry were taken and I soon became eased to believe that I being listened to and relevant details were being noted. My subsequent initial assessment interview was just as thorough and professional, consistent with my previous experience. Choosing a solicitor to act on your behalf is a very important consideration. Although my case is still on going, I have every confidence and peace of mind that I will be concluded well.