Deciding where and which parent a child will live with can be one of the most dreaded aspects of separation. Even where they want to reach an agreement, fears about reduced family time can make conversations about living arrangements particularly difficult.
Although there is no single arrangement that suits every family, the aim should be to establish a safe and workable routine that meets the child’s needs and allows them to feel settled.
Understanding “living with” arrangements
Parents and lawyers often use the words “residence” or “custody” when discussing where their child will live. However, the relevant court order now refers to a child arrangements order, which specifies whom a child lives with and when they spend time with another person, and replaces the former residence and contact orders.
Where both parents are named as people the child lives with, this recognises that the child has a home with each of them, although the time spent in those homes may differ.
A “lives with” arrangement does not give one parent unrestricted authority over their upbringing, and provided both parents have parental responsibility, important decisions will still require consultation, subject to any relevant court order stating otherwise.
If there is no dispute between the parents and they agree where their child will live without asking a court to decide, no order is generally necessary.
Children can live with both parents
A child can live with both parents following separation, although shared living arrangements do not have to involve an equal division of time. For some families, alternating weeks works well because both homes are close to school and each parent can manage the ordinary demands of the school week. In another family, a child might spend more school nights with one parent but have substantial time with the other during weekends and holidays.
The suitability of either arrangement depends on the individual child and the family’s circumstances. Equal time may provide continuity where both parents have always shared daily responsibilities, but it can become exhausting if the child faces a lengthy journey whenever they move between homes.
Practical considerations that shape the arrangement
The following are common areas of dispute:
- School is often central to discussions about where a child will live, and remaining close to an established school can help preserve friendships and give the child some continuity during a period of considerable change.
- Distance between homes matters for similar reasons; a journey that feels manageable at the weekend may be much harder before school, particularly when traffic is unpredictable. Parents should consider whether the child can arrive rested and ready to learn, rather than whether the journey is technically possible.
- A parent who works shifts may still provide substantial care, especially if their rota is predictable; however, a proposal should explain how childcare will work in practice, including what happens when a shift changes unexpectedly.
- Keeping children with their siblings will often be the best option, although their individual needs may sometimes justify different arrangements. An older teenager’s commitments, for example, may make a routine suitable for a much younger sibling impractical.
Neither parent takes priority
Neither parent has a stronger claim for the child to live with them because of their gender, and being the mother does not guarantee that the child will live primarily with her. What each parent has done for the child can nevertheless be significant; for example, if one has managed the lion’s share of daily care, it may help explain the child’s attachments and established routines.
The question is whether the proposed arrangement is realistic and meets the child’s needs, taking account of how the family has functioned so far.
When a court decision becomes necessary
When discussions reach a stalemate, parents may need to ask the family court to determine where their child should live. Court intervention can also be necessary where an informal agreement would leave a child exposed to harm. Any immediate concerns about safety should be raised promptly so that urgent steps can be considered to protect the child.
The judge’s task is to decide which arrangement best serves the child’s welfare. The statutory welfare checklist provides a framework for that decision, requiring consideration of the child’s individual needs and how a proposed move or new routine might affect them. Each parent’s capacity to provide suitable care will also be examined. Where there are concerns about past harm or future risk, these must be considered as part of the overall assessment.
The court can request a report from Cafcass to help it understand the family’s circumstances. If parents give conflicting accounts of events that could affect the outcome, the court will decide whether those matters require further investigation or a separate fact finding hearing.
Changing living arrangements later
Living arrangements need to accommodate the realities of a child’s life, which may look quite different several years after their parents separate. A teenager may find that moving between homes interrupts revision or makes doing their hobbies difficult. Equally, changes in a parent’s circumstances could allow them to take a greater role in everyday care, making a different pattern worth exploring.
Where arrangements are informal, parents can discuss what needs to change and settle on a revised approach. Involving the child appropriately in those discussions can help them understand what to expect, without leaving them feeling responsible for the decision. A gradual transition may also make the new routine easier to manage.
If arrangements are governed by a court order, agreeing occasional flexibility does not alter its legal terms. Parents considering a permanent adjustment should therefore take advice about having the order varied, so that it accurately records the arrangement they intend to follow. Where they disagree, an application can be made for the court to determine whether a change would be appropriate.
If you would like advice on child residence and living arrangements, please get in touch with our team. We can help you address concerns about your child’s current routine or explore how their care could be organised following separation.
View related pages:
Or call us: +44 (0)20 7430 8470